Vegan Steak Recipe with Vital Wheat Gluten

Three country fried vegan steaks on a cream colored plate.

Growing up in the Seventh-day Adventist Church, plant-based cooking was simply the way we ate. Long before "vegan" was a trend, Adventist home cooks were making their own gluten protein from scratch - and this seitan steak recipe is a direct descendant of that tradition. What makes this version different from anything you'll find on a grocery store shelf or most recipe blogs is the broth.

A deeply layered combination of George Washington Brown Broth Powder, Vegemite, hickory smoked torula yeast, liquid aminos, and a touch of instant coffee creates a rich, savory cooking liquid that the gluten steaks absorb over a long, slow simmer. The result is a tender, flavorful steak that is delicious eaten straight from the pot, battered and fried for a comforting country dinner, or sliced into strips for fajitas.

This recipe makes a generous batch of about 23 steaks - perfect for feeding a family, stocking the freezer, and having a homemade plant-based protein ready all week long.

Jump to:

This is the Recipe I Grew Up With - Here's Why You'll Love it
What You'll Need to Make These Gluten Steaks
Let's Make Them - Step by Step
Storing These Steaks (They Keep Beautifully!)
Ways to Switch It Up
A Few Tips Before You Start
Your Questions Answered
So Many Ways to Put These to Work
More Recipes You Might Love
📖 Recipe
💬 Comments

This is the Recipe I Grew Up With - Here's Why You'll Love it

Batch cooking made easy. One pot gives you around 23 steaks that divide beautifully into family portions for the freezer. Make it on a Sunday and you're set for weeks.
The broth is everything. The layered, savory cooking liquid is what sets this recipe apart. These steaks are seasoned all the way through, not just on the outside.
Good old-fashioned homemade protein. Making your own seitan costs a fraction of store-bought meat alternatives, and the flavor and texture are genuinely better.
Endlessly versatile. Eat them straight from the broth, bread and fry them, toss them in fajitas - they work anywhere you'd reach for beef.

Ingredients from top going clockwise, coconut aminos, vegemite, garlic powder, hickory smoked torula yeast, broth powder, oil,

What You'll Need to Make These Gluten Steaks

For the Steaks

Vital wheat gluten - The protein base of the recipe. See the FAQ section below for more on what this ingredient is and how it behaves.
Water - Just 3 cups to bring the dough together.

For the Broth

Onion and celery - Sautéed first to build the base of the broth.
Extra virgin olive oil - For sautéing the vegetables.
Water - 10 cups to create a full simmer bath for the steaks.
Liquid aminos - A protein concentrate made from soybeans, similar to soy sauce but with a smoother, less salty flavor. Adds deep savory notes to the broth.
Hickory smoked torula yeast - One of the secret weapons here. Vegan, sugar-free, and salt-free, the hickory smoked variety gives the steaks a subtle smokiness that liquid smoke alone cannot replicate.
George Washington Rich Brown Broth Powder - A vegan broth powder that contributes deep, beefy-tasting richness to the cooking liquid. Two packets go into the broth.
Vegemite - A yeast extract paste packed with umami and B vitamins. It adds a savory, malty depth that has been a staple in plant-based cooking for generations. A little goes a long way.
Instant coffee - A small amount deepens the color and adds a subtle roasted bitterness that rounds out the broth. You will not taste coffee in the finished steaks, but you would notice its absence.
Garlic powder - Background flavor throughout the broth.

Broth with vegan steaks before the steaks expanded in the broth.

Let's Make Them - Step by Step

Step 1: Build the Broth

Heat the olive oil in a large stockpot over medium-high heat. Add the diced onion and celery and cook for about 3 minutes, until softened and fragrant.

Add the water, liquid aminos, hickory smoked torula yeast, George Washington broth powder, Vegemite, instant coffee, and garlic powder. Stir well and bring to a full boil.

Step 2: Mix the Dough (Work Fast!)

While the broth comes to a boil, pour 3 cups of water into a large bowl and add the vital wheat gluten flour. Mix quickly - this dough comes together almost instantly. Knead only until the water is fully absorbed and a cohesive dough forms. Overworking develops too much gluten and results in tough steaks instead of tender ones. The whole process should take well under 2 minutes.

Step 3: Shape and Slice

Turn the dough onto a work surface and roll into a log about 2 inches in diameter. Slice into rounds about ¼ to ½ inch thick. The steaks will nearly double in size during cooking, so err on the thinner side.

Step 4: Simmer Low and Slow

Place the sliced steaks into the boiling broth in a single layer - do not stack them, as they will fuse together as the gluten expands. Reduce the heat to medium-low, cover partially, and simmer for 4 to 6 hours.

This long, unhurried simmer is the heart of the recipe. The steaks absorb the savory broth deeply as they cook, becoming tender and fully seasoned throughout - far more flavorful than steaming or a quick boil. They'll expand first, then gradually firm back up over the full cooking time.

Homemade Vegan Steaks simmering in the broth.

Storing These Steaks (They Keep Beautifully!)

One of the best things about this recipe is how well it keeps.

In the refrigerator: Store the cooked steaks fully submerged in their cooking broth in an airtight container. The broth acts as a natural preservative, keeping them fresh and flavorful for up to 2 weeks - much longer than most refrigerated seitan.

In the freezer: Divide into family-sized portions with broth, and freeze for up to 3 months. Freezing in the broth preserves both texture and flavor. Thaw in the refrigerator the day before you plan to serve.

Ways to Switch It Up

Chicken-style seitan: Swap the beef-flavored broth for a lighter version using vegetable stock and poultry seasoning, and skip the torula yeast and instant coffee. Batter and fry these lighter steaks and serve with tartar sauce - they have a texture that reminds many people of pan-fried sea scallops. Wonderful.
Soy sauce: Works in place of liquid aminos if that's what you have on hand. Tamari works too.
Liquid smoke: If you can't find hickory smoked torula yeast, a few drops of liquid smoke can stand in. Use sparingly - it's much more concentrated.
Nutritional yeast: Stir ½ cup into the vital wheat gluten flour before mixing for a slightly cheesy, nutty flavor in the finished steaks.

A Few Tips Before You Start

Quick hands win. Vital wheat gluten activates on contact with water. The faster you mix and the less you knead, the more tender the finished steak. Watch the video above to see the right consistency.
Don't stack the steaks in the pot. They expand as they cook and will fuse together if layered. Give each one its own space.
Use a big pot. These steaks nearly double in size during the first hour before shrinking back down. A pot that is too small makes even cooking difficult.
Keep the simmer gentle. A hard rolling boil can make the texture spongy. Low and slow gives the best results.

Homemade meat substitute that has been simmered in a broth.

Your Questions Answered

What is vital wheat gluten?

Vital wheat gluten is a concentrated flour made entirely from the protein found in wheat. Regular wheat flour is hydrated to activate the gluten proteins, then the starch is washed away and the remaining gluten is dried and ground into a fine powder. It is not quite a flour in the traditional sense - it behaves more like a binder and structural agent. Just ¼ cup contains roughly 23 grams of protein, 4 grams of carbohydrates, and almost no fat.

Is this recipe gluten-free?

No. Vital wheat gluten is the entire basis of the recipe and cannot be substituted if you need a gluten-free result. If you have celiac disease or a gluten intolerance, this recipe is not appropriate for you.

Are seitan steaks and gluten steaks the same thing?

They refer to the same basic product - a protein made from wheat gluten - but the cooking method varies by recipe. Some seitan recipes wrap the dough in foil and steam it. This recipe uses a long, slow simmer in flavored broth, which allows the steaks to absorb flavor throughout rather than just on the surface.

Does vegan steak taste like beef?

Not exactly - and that is not the goal. These steaks have their own satisfying, savory, hearty flavor that comes from the broth ingredients rather than trying to perfectly replicate beef. Many people who grew up eating these in plant-based households find them deeply comforting on their own terms.

Can I eat these straight from the broth?

Yes! The steaks are fully cooked and flavorful enough to eat directly from the pot, served over rice or mashed potatoes with the broth ladled on top. No additional cooking is required, though many people prefer to pan-fry or batter-fry them before serving.

A cast iron skillet with vegan steak fajitas and 3 flour tortillas to the right of the skillet.

So Many Ways to Put These to Work

These gluten steaks are a true kitchen workhorse. Here are the most popular ways to use them:

Vegetarian Chicken Fried Steaks - Batter and double-fry the steaks until golden and crispy, then smother with homemade country-style gravy made with almond milk. This is a beloved comfort food in Adventist households and the dish I reach for on holidays and Sunday dinners.

Vegan Steak Fajitas - Slice the steaks into strips and sauté with bell peppers, onions, and homemade taco seasoning for a quick, satisfying weeknight dinner.

Pan-fried with gravy - Heat a little oil in a cast iron skillet and sear the steaks until browned on both sides. Serve with mushroom gravy and mashed potatoes or mashed cauliflower.

Sandwiches and wraps - Slice thinly and layer into sandwiches or wraps with your favorite condiments and vegetables.

Stir-fries and stews - Cube or slice and use anywhere you would use beef in a stir-fry, stew, or soup.

More Recipes You Might Love

📖 Recipe