First Published: December 17, 2008… Last Updated: November 6, 2019
Eggnog Thumbprint Cookies are a soft cookie base with creamy eggnog flavored filling. They make a festive addition to your holiday cookie tray. Whether you are serving them at a party or giving them away as a gift! If you love eggnog, then you will want to make these cookies!
These tender, delicious bites of heaven are perfect for comforting your soul when it’s cold outside. Snuggle up in your favorite spot with a blanket some Eggnog Thumbprint cookies. Add a hot beverage and a good book for a relaxing afternoon!
While I love trying new cookies out for the holidays, it can be overwhelming when making too many. I like to have a variety of cookies to put out for Christmas Eve. I normally will start in November and freeze the cookies I have made. That way, I can be sure to have that colorful tray of Christmas Cookies.
Making and Storing Eggnog Thumbprint Cookies
Thumbprint Cookies are awesome. They all start with a base cookie, and the filling can be anything you want! I love these Eggnog Thumbprint Cookies, the bite of rum that comes through with the sprinkled nutmeg is absolutely delicious.
Freeze first, fill later or fill now and freeze. Either way works and depending on your situation, one may be better than the other.
Filled Thumbprint Cookies for any Holiday
Eggnog Thumbprint cookies are great for any holiday or event. No matter what the occasion, you can always make the base cookie and fill it with whatever you want to! Below are just a few ideas to make the holidays fun and festive!
Christmas: The Eggnog Thumbprint or a Peppermint flavor with candy sprinkles.
Thanksgiving: Pumpkin or Pecan Pie flavors.
Fall: Apple or pear filling
Patriotic Holidays: Vanilla or cheesecake flavor filling with chopped berry topping.
Easter: Coconut or Malted flavors, maybe some chopped robin eggs for color.
Valentine: Try Chocolate mint flavors, or sub Fireball Whisky subbed for the rum in these eggnog thumbprint cookies. Then, sprinkle with a little cinnamon or red hot cinnamon candies.
Spring: Fill with your favorite spring flavors, berries, jams, cheesecake.
Tips for making Eggnog Thumbprint Cookies
Be sure to chill the dough but not for more than an hour. Longer than that they dough will be hard to handle
Use a piping bag instead of “spooning” the filling. It works wonderfully!
Use spiced rum instead of rum extract to intensify that “authentic” eggnog flavor.
Don’t be afraid to put a good thumbprint dent in that cookie!
Be generous with the eggnog filling, double the filling recipe if you need to.
What you need to make Eggnog Thumbprint Cookies
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. This post contains affiliate links.
Rum or Rum Extract: If just adults will consume these cookies, opt for the rum. However, if you don’t have it on hand or will be giving these to a family with children, go for the rum extract. Just add milk in place of the rum so your filling will be creamy.
Piping Bag: These make filling the cookies SO much easier and neater!
Fresh Nutmeg: There is nothing better than a sprinkle of freshly grated nutmeg.
Microplane: I use this Microplane to grate the whole nutmeg and sprinkle over top of the cookies. A Microplane has many great uses in the kitchen and I will never be without one!
More Thumbprint Cookie recipes you may like
For those living low carb and keto lifestyle, it doesn’t mean you have to go without! Try Lemon Curd Thumbprints or Strawberry Rhubarb Thumbprint Cookies. Both are delicious! Make this eggnog version by making the dough of either recipe and sub the sugar-free sweetener in the filling! Easy peasy!
Eggnog Thumbprint Cookies are a soft cookie base with a creamy eggnog flavored filling. These are perfect for your holiday cookie tray, whether you are serving them at a party, or giving them away as a gift!
In a large bowl beat 3/4 cup butter till softened. Add sugar and brown sugar and beat till fluffy. Beat in egg, vanilla, and salt and beat well. Add flour and beat till well mixed. Cover and chill about 1 hour or till easy to handle.
Shape into 1-inch balls. Place 2 inches apart on a parchment paper-lined baking sheet. Press down centers with thumb. Bake 12 minutes or till done. Remove from oven and cool completely on wire racks.
For the filling, in a small bowl beat 1/4 cup butter till softened. Add powdered sugar and beat till fluffy. Add rum and beat well. Spoon about 1/2 teaspoon filling into the center of each cookie. Sprinkle with nutmeg. Chill till filling is firm.
*You may substitute 1 tablespoon milk and 1/4 teaspoon rum extract for the rum.
Eggnog Thumbprint Cookies
Amount Per Serving (1 cookie)
Calories 98Calories from Fat 45
% Daily Value*
Saturated Fat 3g19%
* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2000 calorie diet.
Shelby is the author/owner of Grumpy's Honeybunch. Established in 2007, she shares and preserves family recipes as well as recipes for cooking light and keto. She is an experienced, self-taught home cook who loves to share recipes with others. You can see her work on websites such as Veal Made Easy, Parade, Community Table, SoFab Food, Yummly, and FoodGawker.
Welcome! I'm Shelby, author of Grumpy's Honeybunch. I have been sharing family favorite recipes since 2007. I started the Keto Diet in October 2017 and since then I have been creating Keto ... read more
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.