- 1-½ sticks unsalted butter, softened
- ⅛ cup smooth peanut butter
- 2-½ cups confectioners sugar
- 4-6 tablespoons milk
- 4 peanut butter filled Oreo cookies, cream removed and wafer part of the cookie crushed (set both aside - cream and cookie crumbs will be used in the frosting)
- Extra Oreo cookies for decorating, cut in half
- With electric hand mixer, blend butter and peanut butter until smooth and creamy. Add confectioner sugar ½ cup at a time, blending until completely blended each time. Add the cream from the cookie and blend well. Add milk, 1 tablespoon at a time, until frosting is the creamy consistency that you like. Fold in ½ of the cookie crumbs. Decorate & enjoy!
Kristen
I didn't even know that Oreo made peanut butter filled cookies...I really need to get out more. Knowing how moist mayo cakes are, those cupcakes have to be delicious!
Barbara Bakes
Everything's better with Oreo's on top!
Gera @ Sweets Foods Blog
I know was the birthday Theresa but I want them to say happy birthday to me!!
Cheers,
Gera
Kristen
Seeing the words "fitness updates" and then these delicious cupcakes in the same post seems like torture 🙂 These look fantastic - and healthy too, right? Right? 🙂
baking.serendipity
Two amazing flavors in one...delicious 🙂 I've made Oreo cupcakes/frosting before, but never thought to add in the peanut butter as well. What a great idea!
Cristine
Oreo peanut butter frosting??? You are killing me, Shelby! Looks great!
ajcabuang04
These look sooo great!! They look so moist and decadent!!
Pam
I wish you would make these for me for my b-day. YUM!
Just Food Snobs
Thanks for sharing! I love cupcakes and always looking for new things to do with frosting, since my husband loves peanut butter and chocolate I would love to try this frosting recipe. Thanks!
pigpigscorner
Awesome flavours! and I like the oreo on top!
ceecee
Oh gosh. These look sooo good.
susies1955
WOW, they look SO awesome. YUM!
Susie
Maria
Mmmmm! These look fantastic!
Cathy
I love the chocolate - peanut butter flavor combo with an Oreo decoration. Delish!
Carol Egbert
What an amazing idea to deconstruct the Oreo cookie and use the cream in the frosting.
Amanda
Oh yum Shelby! Those sound great and look even better!
Donna-FFW
What a fantastic , fabulous sounding frosting. I love it. The cupcakes look gorgeous, lucky Theresa!
pegasuslegend
very mouth watering, havent had an oreo cookie in about 25 years. You just gave me a reason to buy them! Wowow!!
bellini valli
Yum Shelby:D
Marthe
Those cupcakes look really yummy! I voted 😉